Linux Phones Are Mature - But US Carriers Won't Allow Them

Today I looked into the status of some of the Linux phones, which are mature now.

Librem is one of the ones most people have heard about, but the price point on it is out of reach for anyone daring enough to jump in the pool and start swimming with a Linux phone.

Pinephone looks like it has a pretty darn nice Linux phone now, but after watching a few reviews, it is pretty clear that you need to go with the Pinephone Pro, and put a fast(er) Linux OS on it. 

The main issue with performance on these phones, has to do with the graphics rendering. If you are running the Gnome Desktop for example, the GUI is going to take up most of the cycles and resources that you want for your applications. I learned this on regular Linux running on desktop servers years ago, and got into the habit of installing a more lightweight KDE desktop to try and get some of my resources back under my control.

Today, I found a German phone that apparently is really gaining in popularity in Europe - especially Germany. It is called Volla Phone.  Super nice phone, and they have done some work selecting the hardware components and optimizing the Linux distro for you, so that you don't have to spend hours and hours tweaking, configuring, and putting different OS images on the phone to squeeze performance out of it.

Volla Phone - Linux Privacy Phone

 

Problem is - United States carriers don't allow these phones! They are not on the "Compatibility List". Now, I understand there might be an FCC cost to certifying devices on a cellular network (I have not verified this). The frequencies matter of course, but the SIM cards also matter. Volla Phone will, for instance, apparently work on T-Mobile, but only if you have an older SIM card. If you are on T-Mobile and have a new SIM card, then it won't work because of some fields that aren't exchanged (if I understand correctly).

Carriers that are in bed with Google and Apple, such as at&t and Verizon, they're going to do everything they can to prevent a Linux BYOD (Bring Your Own Device) phone hitting their network. They make too much $$$$$$$$$$$$ off of Apple and Android. T-Mobile, they're German of course, so maybe they have a little bit more of the European mindset. These are your three network rollouts across the United States, and all of your mom and pop cellular plays (i.e. Spectrum Mobile, Cricket, et al) are just MVNOs riding on that infrastructure. 

So if you have one of these Linux phones, you can use it in your home. On WiFi. But if you carry it outdoors, it's a brick apparently. Here we are in 2024, and that STILL seems to be the case.